Meet the Team

At Garner Insurance, our number one priority is you, the client.

Since the very beginning, Garner Insurance has been focused on our client’s. We offer advice you can trust from professionals in the industry as well as additional support from some of the best Insurance Carriers anywhere. We pride ourselves in individualizing your coverage as well as your experience within our agency. There is no “cookie cutter” solution to your insurance needs and we would not minimize your importance to us by simply trying to “sell” you an insurance policy.

At our firm, we have the client—and only the client—in mind.

Our process is specifically tailored to assist you with understanding and properly covering your insurance needs. To address those needs we offer a full insurance review in the place you are most comfortable. Due to COVID19, we have adjusted our personal visits to in office at 2275 W. Fair Ave., Lancaster, OH by appointment only, permitting social distancing and appropriate time for sanitizing.  We can also conduct virtual appointments, which allows our clients to meet with our insurance specialists from the comfort of their home. 

We have built a very strong team with over 80 years combined experience to help meet all of your insurance needs. In addition to the specialists who meet with clients individually, all our staff are licensed agents who are available to assist clients in the day to day insurance needs that may arise. Our CSR's (Client Service Representatives) are the experts in quoting, policy changes, guidance to file a claim as well as general questions.  If the staff feels that further discussion would benefit you, the client, they are able to set a review appointment with a specialist.

We are here when you need us!

Client Centered

Client Centered

Whether you are looking for help protecting your family, your home, or your assets, our personalized service focuses on your needs, wants, and long-term goals.

Our team has years of experience in the insurance industry. We can help you address your needs of today and for many years to come. We look forward to working with you.

Contact Us